Buckeye Candy Company Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Buckeye Candy Company, where nostalgia meets a vibrant world of sweets! Nestled in Columbus, Ohio, this delightful dessert haven offers a treasure trove of candy that caters to every sweet tooth. The menu bursts with offerings, from gummi candies like Gummi Awesome Blossoms and Giant Gummi Frogs to indulgent fudge trays featuring mouthwatering Peanut Butter Fudge and Turtle Pecan Fudge.
- Gummi Delights: An assortment to satisfy your gummy cravings.
- Sour Candy: Featuring flavors like Sour Cherry Bears for a zesty kick.
- Fudge Tray Heaven: Rich, creamy fudge variations that are perfect for sharing.
With friendly staff ready to assist, Buckeye Candy Company is more than just a candy store; it’s a joyful exploration into the world of sweets. Each visit promises new finds, making it an unforgettable destination for candy lovers!
Gummi Candy
12 Flavor Gummi Bears Candy
$5.75
Gummi Giant Papa Bears Candy
$5.75
Gummi Butterflies Candy
$5.75
Gummi Awesome Blossoms Candy
$5.75
Gummi Bear Cubs Candy
$5.75
Champagne Gummi Bears Candy
Non alcoholic.
$3.25
Crispy Crunch Gummi Bears Candy
$5.75
Gummi Peachy Penguins Candy
$5.75
3D Gummi Penguins Candy
$5.75
Gummi Alphabet Letters Candy
$5.75
4D Gummi Lego Bricks Candy
$5.75
Giant Gummi Sharks Candy
$5.75
Gummi Pigs Candy
$3.25
Gummi Rainforest Frogs Candy
$5.75
Gummi Filled Sea Turtles Candy
$5.75
Gummi Starfish Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Gummi Unicorns Candy
$5.75
Gummi Lobsters Candy
All red.
$5.75
Gummi Chicken Feet Candy
Cherry.
$5.75
Gummi Dinosaurs Candy
$5.75
Gummi Robots Candy
$5.75
Gummi Pizza Slices Candy
$5.75
Gummi Fried Eggs Candy
$5.75
Gummi Twin Cherries Candy
$5.75
Gummi Red Raspberries Candy
$5.75
Gummi Teeth Candy
$5.75
Gummi Brains Candy
$5.75
Gummi Peach Rings Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Giant Gummi Worms Candy
$5.75
Giant Gummi Snake Candy
3 feet long.
$3.25
Giant Gummi Frogs Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Giant Gummi Spiders Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Gummi Bananas Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Bubblegum Bottles Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Gummi Cola Bottles Candy
$5.75
Juju Coins Candy
$5.75
Swedish Fish Candy
$5.75
Strawberry Puffs Candy
Sugar coated.
$5.75
Raspberries and Blackberries Candy
$5.75
Gummi Hot Chili Peppers Candy
$3.25
Red Mini Swedish Fish
$5.75
Gummi Apple Rings
Sugar Coated
$5.75
Sour Gummi Bears Candy
$5.75
Sour Gummi Mini Worms Candy
$5.75
Sour Gummi Poppers Candy
$5.75
Sour Twin Cherries Candy
$5.75
Sour Grapefruit Candy
$5.75
Sour Rainbow Belts Candy
$5.75
Sour Gummi Octopus Candy
$5.75
Sour Patch Fruit Salad Candy
$5.75
Sour Patch Watermelons Candy
$5.75
Sour Patch Kids Candy
$5.75
Sour Cherry Cola Bottles Candy
$5.75
Sour Cola Bottles Candy
$5.75
Sour Cherry Bears Candy
$5.75
Sour Blue Raspberry Bears Candy
$5.75
Sour Fruit Balls Candy
$5.75
Sour Dinosaur Eggs Candy
$5.75
Sour Blue Raspberry Bottles
$5.75
Sour Candy
Fudge Trays
Buckeye Fudge Tray
Rich creamy mix of peanut butter and chocolate fudge, creating an Ohio classic!
$9.75
Maple Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Sea Salted Caramel Fudge
6oz tray
$9.95
Peanut Butter Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Chocolate Walnut Fudge
6 oz tray
$9.95
Rocky Road Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Turtle Pecan Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Cookies & Cream Fudge
6 oz tray
$9.95
Chocolate Fudge
6 oz tray
$9.95
Peanut Butter Fudge
6 oz tray
$9.95
Maple Pecan Fudge
6 oz tray
$9.95
Peanut Butter Fudge Cup
3oz
$3.75
Chocolate Fudge Cup
3oz
$3.75
Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge Cup
3oz
$3.75
Chocolate Walnut Fudge Cup
3oz
$3.75
Vanilla Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
White Chocolate Peppermint Chip Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Cookie Breakup Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Sea Salted Caramel Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Sugar Free Chocolate Vanilla Fudge Tray
12oz
$16.50
Sugar Free Peanut Butter Fudge Tray
12oz
$16.50
Cookie Dough Fudge Tray
12oz
$14.50
Birthday Cake Fudge - 12oz
$14.50
Caramel Apple Fudge - 12oz
$14.50
Fruit Slices
$3.25
Mini Fruit Slices
$3.25
Candy Guppies
$5.75
Candy Lego Blocks
$5.75
Unicorn Poop
$5.75
Rainbow Laces
$5.75
Cinnamon Bears
$5.75
Chewy Spree
$5.75
Mellocreme Pumpkins
$3.25
Skittles
$5.75
Runts
$5.75
Tire Tracks Licorice
$3.25
Hot Tamales
$3.25
Good 'n Plenty
$3.25
Black Licorice Scottie Dogs
$5.75
Black Licorice Allsorts
$5.75
Black Licorice Bullseyes
$5.75
Caramel Bullseyes
$5.75
Chocolate Bullseyes
$5.75
Mini Cowtails
$3.25
Bit 'o Honey
$3.25
Jolly Rancher
$5.75
Airheads
$5.75
Warheads
$3.25
Tootsie Rolls
$5.75
Gummi Ring Pops
$3.25
Dad's Rootbeer Barrels
$3.25
Sour Extreme Smarties
$3.25
Red/Grey Spirit Mix Sixlets - 1 lb Bag
$10.00
Red/Grey Spirit Mix Sixlets - 1/2 lb Bag
$6.50
Pumpkin Spice Maltballs - 6 oz Bag
$3.50
Pumpkin Spice Maltballs - 1lb Bag
$7.75
Crunchy Candy Pacifiers
$5.75
Psychedelic Jawbreakers
$5.75
Other Bulk Confections
Chocolate Bulk
Milk Chocolate Double Dipped Peanuts
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Raisins
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Pretzels
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Cinnamon Graham Pretzels
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Maltballs
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Gummi Bears
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Pretzels Balls
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Brownie Bites
$5.75
Milk and Dark Chocolate Bridge Mix
$5.75
Peanut Butter Bites
$5.75
Dark Chocolate Maltballs
$5.75
Dark Chocolate Almonds
$5.75
Dark Chocolate Pretzels
$5.75
Candy Chocolate Pebbles
$5.75
Peanut Butter Maltballs
$5.75
Peanut Butter Covered Caramel Corn
$5.75
White Chocolate Almonds
$11.00
Yogurt Covered Animal Crackers
$5.75
Birthday Cake Bites (White Chocolate)
$5.75
Smooth and Melties
$3.25
Reese's Pieces
$5.75
Dark Chocolate Double-Dipped Peanuts
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Almonds
$5.75
Mint Chocolate Cookie Maltballs
$5.75
Sea Salt Dark Chocolate Maltballs
$5.75
Milk Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
$5.75
Dark Chocolate Raisins
$5.75
White Chocolate Pretzels
$5.75
Soda Pop Shoppe Jelly Belly
$3.25
Jewel Collection Jelly Belly
$3.25
JB Sours
$5.75
49 Flavor Assortment Jelly Belly
$5.75
Toasted Marshmallow Jelly Belly
$5.75
Very Cherry Jelly Belly
$5.75
Buttered Popcorn Jelly Belly
$5.75
Cotton Candy Jelly Belly
$3.25
Tutti Fruitti Jelly Belly
$5.75
Juicy Pear Jelly Belly
$5.75
Watermelon Jelly Belly
$3.25
Coconut Jelly Belly
$3.25
Candy Cane Jelly Belly
$3.25
Lemon Lime Jelly Belly
$3.25
Jelly Belly Bulk Jelly Beans
Gourmet Cotton Candy
Alien Fluff Cotton Candy
Sour watermelon.
$5.75
Banana Split Cotton Candy
$5.75
Beer Cotton Candy
$5.75
Birthday Cake Cotton Candy
$5.75
Blue Raspberry Cotton Candy
$5.75
Buttered Popcorn Cotton Candy
$5.75
Champagne Cotton Candy
$5.75
Chardonnay Cotton Candy
$5.75
Cherry Berry Cotton Candy
$5.75
Chocolate Mint Camo Sweets Cotton Candy
$5.75
Classic Pink Vanilla Cotton Candy
$5.75
Cupcake Cotton Candy
$5.75
Frosted Donut Cotton Candy
$5.75
Grape Cotton Candy
$5.75
Hot Chocolate Cotton Candy
$5.75
Key Lime Cotton Candy
$5.75
Merlot Cotton Candy
$5.75
Mimosa Cotton Candy
$5.75
Orange Dreamsicle Cotton Candy
$5.75
PB&J Cotton Candy
$5.75
Peach Cotton Candy
$5.75
Pina Colada Cotton Candy
$5.75
Pineapple Mango Cotton Candy
$5.75
Root Beer Cotton Candy
$5.75
Rose Wine Cotton Candy
$5.75
Strawberry Cheesecake Cotton Candy
$5.75
Strawberry Smoothie Cotton Candy
$5.75
Christmas Cookie Cotton Candy (previously Sugar Cookie)
$5.75
Trump Hair Cotton Candy
$5.75
Unicorn Tails Cotton Candy
$5.75
Watermelon Kiwi Cotton Candy
$5.75
Wedding Cake Cotton Candy
$5.75
Vanilla Bean Cotton Candy
$5.75
Lemonade Cotton Candy
$5.75
Pickle Cotton Candy
$5.75
Buckeye Cotton Candy
Chocolate and Peanut Butter Flavored Cotton Candy
$5.75
Classic Crispy Cake
$6.50
Cookies and Cream Cake
$6.50
Chocolate Dipped Cake
$6.50
S'mores Cake
$6.50
M&M's Cake
$6.50
Jelly Bean Cake
$6.50
Espresso Cake
$6.50
Cafe Mocha Cake
$6.50
Lucky Charms Cake
$6.50
Captain Crunch Cake
$6.50
Froot Loops Cake
$6.50
Worms in Dirt Cake
$6.50
Peanut Butter Fluff Cake
$6.50
Peanut Butter with Chocolate Cake
$6.50
Peanut Butter and Jelly Cake
$6.50
Sprinkles Covered Cake
$6.50
Mini Marshmallow Chocolate Drizzle Cake
$6.50
Chocolate Toffee Crunch Cake
$6.50
Pretzel Surprise Cake
$6.50
Chocolate Caramel and Peanuts Cake
$6.50
Cocoa Conncoction Cake
$6.50
Popcorn Caramel Cake
$6.50
Rice Crispy Cakes
Retro Candy
Tart n' Tiny Candy
$2.95
Wacky Wafers Candy
$2.95
Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles Candy
$2.95
Super Ropes Candy
$1.95
Candy Cigarettes
$1.50
Chocolate Cigarettes Candy
$2.75
Bubblegum Cigarettes Candy
$2.25
Zotz Strings
$0.75
Candy Buttons
$2.75
Turkish Taffy Candy
$1.95
Astro Pops Candy
$3.95
Oh Henry Bar Candy
$1.95
Watchamacalit Bar Candy
$1.95
Razzles Candy
$1.95
Sour Razzles Candy
$1.95
Black Cow Candy
$1.95
Slo Poke Candy
$1.95
Zero Bar Candy
$1.95
Mallo Cups Candy
$1.95
Peanut Butter Smoothie Candy
Butterscotch.
$1.95
Vanilla Charleston Chew Candy
$2.50
5th Avenue Bar Candy
$1.95
Clarks Peanut Butter Cups Candy
$1.95
Idaho Spud Candy
$2.50
Giant Smarties Candy
$0.75
Chocolate Charleston Chew Candy
$2.50
Strawberry Charleston Chew Candy
$2.50
Haribo Berries Peg Bag
Raspberries and Blackberries - crunchy and chewy candy
$3.25
12 Piece Milk Chocolate Buckeyes
$6.50
12 Piece Dark Chocolate Buckeyes
$6.50
12 Piece White Chocolate Buckeyes
$6.50
Buckeyes - Chocolate
Favorite Chocolate Bars
Hershey's Chocolate Bar
$1.50
Hershey's Milk Chocolate with Almonds
$1.50
Hershey's Cookies and Cream
$1.50
Hershey's Gold Peanuts and Pretzels
$1.50
Hershey's Bar with Reese's Pieces
$1.50
Kit Kat Milk Chocolate
$1.50
Kit Kat Dark Chocolate
$1.50
Kit Kat White Chocolate
$1.50
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
$1.50
White Chocolate Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
$1.50
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups with Reese's Pieces
$1.50
Reese's Take 5
$1.50
Payday
$1.50
York Peppermint Patty
$1.50
Mounds
$1.50
Almond Joy
$1.50
Mini M&M's Tube
$1.50
King Size Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
$2.50
Snickers
$1.50
Snickers Almond
$1.50
Milky Way
$1.50
Dark Chocolate Milky Way
$1.50
Heath Bar
$1.50
Skor
$1.50
Twix Bar - Original
$1.50
Twix - Cookies & Cream Bar
$1.50
Reese's Peanut Butter Lover's Cups
Extra layer of PB on top!
$1.50
Reese's Fast Break Bar
$1.50
3 Muskateers Bar
$1.50
Rolo roll
$1.50
Reese's Outrageous Bar
$1.50
Reese's Nutrageous Bar
$1.50
Snickers Bar - White Chocolate
$1.95
100 Grand Bar
$1.50
Hershey's White Chocolate with Almonds
$1.50
Cocktail Classics Jelly Beans
$3.25
Champagne Jelly Beans
$3.25
Black Licorice Jelly Beans
$3.25
Chocolate Dipped Very Cherry Jelly Beans
$3.25
Black Licorice Bridge Mix Jelly Beans
$3.25
Tobasco Jelly Beans
$3.25
Dr Pepper Jelly Beans
$3.25
Hot Cinnamon Bears
$3.25
Raspberries and Blackberries
$3.25
Superfruit Mix Jelly Beans
$3.25
Sizzling Cinnamon Jelly Beans
$3.25
Recipe Mix Jelly Beans
$3.25
Tropical Mix Jelly Beans
$3.25
Camo Beans Pink Jelly Beans
$3.25
Camo Beans Green Jelly Beans
$3.25
Snapple Mix Jelly Beans
$3.25
Coldstone Creamery Jelly Beans
$3.25
Krispy Kreme Doughnuts Jelly Beans
$3.25
Cotton Candy Jelly Beans
$3.25
Smoothie Blend Jelly Beans
$3.25
Toy Story 4 Jelly Beans
$3.25
Disney Princesses Jelly Beans
$3.25
Star Wars C3P0 Jelly Beans
$3.25
Star Wars BB8 Jelly Beans
$3.25
Superman Jelly Beans
$3.25
Mickey Mouse Jelly Beans
$3.25
Jurassic Park Jelly Beans
$3.25
Sunkist Fruit Jems
$3.25
Jelly Belly Candy Cupcakes
Mellocreme.
$3.25
Beanboozled Flip-Top Box
$2.95
Beanboozled Party Box with Spinner
$8.95
Beanboozled Party Bag
25 count.
$12.50
Jelly Belly Peg Bags
Drinks
Flying Cauldron Butterscotch Beer
$3.50
Orange Crush
Made with cane sugar.
$2.50
Grape Crush
Made with cane sugar.
$2.50
Strawberry Crush
Made with cane sugar.
$2.50
Jolt Cola
$3.50
Duff Beer
Orange energy drink.
$3.50
Unicorn Yak
Raspberry orange cream soda.
$3.50
Sugar Free Jelly Belly Assorted Flavors
$3.25
Sugar Free Jelly Belly Sours
$3.25
Sugar Free Jelly Belly Gummi Bears
$3.25
Sugar Free Cola Bottles
$4.25
Sugar Free Gummi Fish (Berry Flavored)
$4.25
Sugar Free Gummi Pigs (Fruit Flavored Marshmallow Candy)
$4.25
Sugar Free 12-Flavor Gummi Bears
$4.00
Sugar Free Taffy (Assorted Flavors)
$3.50
Sugar Free Werther's Original Chewy Caramels
$2.75